Why Many Rock Guitarists Struggle with “Vertical” Improvisation

Improvising over chord changes is a skill that separates seasoned musicians from those who stick to more basic soloing techniques. In rock music, this distinction is often seen in the difference between “horizontal” soloing, where the guitarist sticks to a single key or scale, and “vertical” soloing, where they address each chord change as it happens. Many rock guitarists, even those with years of experience, struggle to move beyond horizontal soloing and find themselves limited when trying to navigate complex chord progressions.

The Horizontal Approach

The pentatonic scale, particularly the minor pentatonic, is the go-to scale for many rock guitarists. Its five-note structure is simple to memorize and easy to apply across a variety of musical contexts. For example, in a song like “Black Magic Woman,” a rock guitarist might instinctively lean on the D minor pentatonic scale throughout the entire progression:

| Dm | % | A7 | % | | Dm | % | Gm | % | Dm | A7 | Dm | Dm (break) |

While the D minor pentatonic scale contains notes that fit well over the D minor chord, it doesn’t always capture the nuances of the other chords in the progression, such as A7 and Gm. This is where horizontal soloing falls short—it glosses over the individual harmonic qualities of each chord in favor of a more generalized approach.

The Vertical Approach

“Vertical” improvisation involves addressing each chord as it comes, selecting notes that reflect the specific harmony of that chord. This technique requires a deeper understanding of music theory, including scales, arpeggios, and chord tones. In the context of “Black Magic Woman,” a guitarist using a vertical approach might:

• Use the D minor pentatonic scale or D Dorian mode over the Dm chord.
• Switch to the A Mixolydian mode or an A7 arpeggio over the A7 chord to highlight the chord tones, including the critical C# (the major third of A7) that isn’t present in the D minor pentatonic scale.
• Move to the G Dorian mode or a G minor arpeggio over the Gm chord.

This approach involves more than just scale knowledge. It requires an intuitive understanding of how each chord functions within the progression and the ability to visualize these changes on the fretboard.

Why Rock Guitarists Struggle with Vertical Improvisation

Several factors contribute to the difficulty rock guitarists face when attempting to solo “vertically”:

1. Reliance on Pentatonic Patterns: Many rock guitarists begin their learning journey with the minor pentatonic scale. This scale is forgiving and works well in many rock contexts. However, it doesn’t provide the harmonic complexity needed to outline more advanced chord progressions accurately. Over-reliance on pentatonic shapes can lead to solos that sound static and disconnected from the underlying harmony.
2. Lack of Theoretical Knowledge: Rock music education often emphasizes feel, expression, and raw emotion over theoretical concepts like chord-scale relationships and voice leading. While this focus is essential for developing a unique style, it can leave guitarists ill-equipped to handle complex chord changes, especially those involving non-diatonic chords.
3. Limited Exposure to Jazz and Fusion: In genres like jazz and fusion, improvisation is heavily based on navigating chord changes with modes, arpeggios, and chromaticism. Rock guitarists who haven’t studied these styles may not have had the opportunity to develop the skills required for vertical improvisation. Jazz guitarists, for example, are trained to target chord tones (root, third, fifth, and seventh) and use modes that reflect each chord’s unique harmonic structure.
4. Riff-Based Playing: Rock music often revolves around riff-based structures and repeating patterns. This riff-based approach can make it challenging for guitarists to break out of a pattern and adapt their playing to each chord change dynamically. While riffs are effective in creating memorable hooks, they don’t necessarily provide the fluidity needed for improvising over changing harmonies.

Learning to Improvise Vertically

Improvising “vertically” requires a combination of theoretical understanding, fretboard visualization, and practical application. Here are some steps that can help guitarists move beyond horizontal soloing:

1. Master Arpeggios Across the Fretboard

Arpeggios are the building blocks of vertical improvisation. They contain the essential notes of a chord—root, third, fifth, and sometimes the seventh. Learning arpeggio shapes for different chord types (major, minor, dominant, diminished, etc.) all over the neck allows you to outline the chord changes in a progression. For example, in “Black Magic Woman,” you could use a D minor arpeggio (D, F, A) over the Dm chord and an A7 arpeggio (A, C#, E, G) over the A7 chord.

2. Visualize Chord Tones Within Scales

Instead of relying solely on scale patterns, focus on visualizing chord tones within those scales. In the D minor pentatonic scale, identify the notes that belong to the current chord. For the A7 chord, make sure to emphasize the notes A, C#, E, and G. This approach allows you to play melodically while being informed by the harmony, resulting in solos that sound more connected to the music.

3. Practice Targeting Chord Changes

Practice exercises that involve targeting specific chord tones when the chords change. For instance, when moving from Dm to A7, target the note C# on the first beat of the A7 chord. This technique, known as “chord tone soloing,” helps reinforce the sound of each chord in your mind and under your fingers. Over time, you’ll develop an intuitive sense of where these target notes lie on the fretboard.

4. Incorporate Modes and Altered Scales

While modes are often associated with jazz, they can be incredibly useful for rock guitarists looking to enhance their improvisational skills. In “Black Magic Woman,” using D Dorian over the Dm chord and A Mixolydian over the A7 chord provides the specific notes needed to outline the harmony effectively. For more advanced changes, explore altered scales like the diminished or altered dominant scales to add tension and resolution in your solos.

5. Listen and Transcribe

Listen to guitarists known for their ability to navigate chord changes effectively, such as Larry Carlton, Robben Ford, and John Scofield. Transcribing solos from jazz or fusion players can also provide insight into how to approach vertical improvisation. Notice how these guitarists use arpeggios, target chord tones, and change their note choices to match the underlying harmony.

The Benefits of Vertical Improvisation

Developing the ability to solo “vertically” opens up new dimensions in your playing. It allows you to:

• Create More Melodically Rich Solos: By reflecting the chord changes in your improvisation, your solos will sound more cohesive and harmonically rich.
• Add Emotional Depth: Vertical soloing can bring out the emotional qualities of each chord. For example, emphasizing the major third of a dominant chord can create a sense of resolution, while highlighting the minor seventh can add tension.
• Interact with Other Musicians: In a band setting, being able to respond to chord changes allows for a more interactive and dynamic musical conversation.

Conclusion

While rock guitarists often excel in creating expressive solos within a given key, the ability to improvise “vertically” by addressing each chord change is a valuable skill that can greatly enhance one’s musicality. By mastering arpeggios, visualizing chord tones, and incorporating modes, guitarists can break free from the limitations of horizontal soloing and create solos that are both harmonically informed and emotionally compelling.

—